Table 1: Data characteristics of studies reviewed.
|
Study Reference |
Study design |
Number of Participants
|
Mean age (SD) |
Dose of ESWT |
Type of CP |
Time of Intervention |
Number of Sessions |
The change in Efficacy outcomes of ESWT compared to CP |
||||||
|
ESWT |
CP |
ESWT |
CP |
ESWT |
CP |
ESWT |
CP |
Pain |
Grip Strength |
Functional Level |
||||
|
Kubot, et al. (2017) [29] |
RCT |
30
|
30 |
47.6 (7.66) years |
43.9 (9.44) |
a) Pulse- 2000 b) Wavelength- 8 Hz c) Pressure -1.5-2.5 bar |
Ultrasound a) Pulsed mode of 0.5 W/cm b) Frequency- 1MHz. |
3 Weeks
|
10 days |
3 (weekly) |
10 (Daily) |
Reduction in Pain
ESWT showed superiority |
NA |
Improved functional levels
Only ESWT was effective |
|
Aydin, et al. (2017) [5] |
RCT |
27
|
19 |
42.9 (10.2) years |
47.5 (9.1) years |
a) Pulse- 1200 b) Wavelength- 3.5 Hz c) Pressure -1.5-2.5 bar |
at least one of the following; a) NSAIDs, b) splints, c) physical treatment |
1 month |
1 month |
4 (weekly) |
4 (weekly) |
Reduction in Pain
ESWT showed superiority |
Improved grip strength
No significant difference between groups |
Improved functional Levels ESWT showed superiority |
|
Yalvaç, et al. (2018) [6] |
RCT |
20 |
24 |
46.04 (9.24) years |
43.75 (4.52) years |
a) Pulse- 2000 b) Wavelength- 10-15 Hz c)Pressure -1.5-2.5 bar |
Ultrasound a) Continuous mode of 1.5 W/cm b) Frequency- 1MHz |
3 weeks |
2 weeks |
3 (weekly) |
10 (5 each week) |
Reduction in Pain
ESWT showed superiority |
Improved grip strength
No significant difference between groups |
Improved functional levels
No significant difference between groups |
|
(Altun, et al. 2018) [30] |
QES |
37 |
36 |
50.4 (7.3) years |
51.6 (7.6) years |
a) Pulse- 1500 b) Wavelength-15 Hz c) Pressure -1.4 -1.6 bar |
PT session (hot pack, US, and TENS) |
3 weeks |
10 days |
3(every 7 to 10 days) |
10 (daily) |
Reduction in Pain
No significant difference between groups |
Improved grip strength
No significant difference between groups |
Improved functional levels
No significant difference between groups |
|
Eraslan, et al. (2017) [10] |
RCT |
15 |
15 |
48 (5.7) |
48.5 (5.6) |
a) Pulse- 2000 b) low-energy fux density |
physiotherapy + kinesiotaping |
3 weeks |
3 weeks |
3 (weekly) |
15 (5 days/ week) |
Reduction in Pain
CP (Kinesiotaping) group showed superiority |
Improved grip strength
CP (Kinesiotaping) group showed superiority |
Improved functional Levels CP (Kinesiotaping) group showed superiority |
RCT: Randomized Control Trial; QES: Quasi Experimental Study; SD: Standard Deviation; PT: Physiotherapy; CP: Conventional Physiotherapy; ESWT: Extracorporeal Shockwave Therapy